The Edmonton Oilers hired Mike Babcock because they wanted a coach who would challenge Evan Bouchard, according to NHL analyst Rhett Warrener.
Speaking on Daily Faceoff Calgary, Warrener offered a blunt explanation for Edmonton’s coaching change. He suggested frustration with Bouchard helped shape the decision to bring Babcock back.
“I think they hired Babcock because they’re all mad at Bouchard, and I’m not joking,” Warrener said.
MORE: ‘He’s the right guy’: Leon Draisaitl backs Mike Babcock with blunt verdict after Oilers hiring
The Oilers fired Kris Knoblauch after their 2025-26 season ended with a first-round loss to the Anaheim Ducks. Edmonton finished 41-30-11 with 93 points, despite ranking among the league’s top offensive teams.
Bouchard had a remarkable regular season, producing 95 points and leading all NHL defensemen in scoring. His offensive impact was undeniable, but his defensive mistakes remained a recurring concern.
That tension became more visible during Edmonton’s playoff exit. Bouchard struggled defensively against Anaheim, reinforcing criticism that his aggressive style can create problems when possessions break down.
Warrener believes the Oilers wanted Babcock to address that issue directly. “They say, well, we need someone hard to push,” Warrener said.
“I don’t think they mean push me,” he added. “I think they mean push our 90-point defenseman.”
Mike Babcock must fix more than Evan Bouchard’s mistakes
Warrener also pointed to visible frustration among Edmonton’s top players. “You’ve seen McDavid and Draisaitl and the rest of the group roll their eyes and have a big sigh,” he said.
He was referring to moments when Bouchard makes risky decisions in Edmonton’s defensive zone. Warrener described one such sequence as Bouchard deciding, “Yeah, we’re going to lay a turd in the middle of our zone.”
Bouchard’s offensive value makes the situation complicated. Asking him to become overly conservative could weaken one of Edmonton’s biggest strengths.
The better solution is greater structure around his decisions. Babcock’s task should involve creating clearer defensive responsibilities without limiting Bouchard’s ability to attack.
Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl have reportedly supported Babcock’s appointment as they chase the Stanley Cup. Draisaitl said the Oilers lacked structure last season and welcomed Babcock’s demanding approach.
That support gives Babcock room to challenge established players. Still, singling out Bouchard would miss the broader issue that ended Edmonton’s season.
The Oilers need better five-man defensive execution, stronger puck management and more consistency from their entire lineup. Bouchard is part of that solution, but he cannot carry the blame alone.
Babcock’s success will depend on whether he can improve those details without disrupting Edmonton’s elite offensive identity.
