The Edmonton Oilers‘ effort to hire veteran coach Mike Babcock has encountered a significant obstacle after the NHL Players’ Association formally requested a league investigation into allegations tied to his brief tenure with the Columbus Blue Jackets.
NHL insider Darren Dreger reported on X that “the NHLPA has asked the NHL to move forward with an investigation into the allegations Mike Babcock invaded players privacy during his time in Columbus.”
Adding further detail, NHL insider Frank Seravalli reported that the NHLPA has “specifically requested that the NHL delay Mike Babcock’s hiring by the Edmonton Oilers until a formal investigation can be completed.”
The development places Edmonton’s coaching search in limbo at a critical moment for the franchise. While the Oilers have not officially announced a hiring, reports have linked the organization closely to Babcock as management searches for answers following a disappointing 2025-26 season.
MORE: ‘The top’: Elliotte Friedman reveals who’s driving Oilers’ Mike Babcock pursuit
Oilers searching for structure after disappointing season
Edmonton entered the season with Stanley Cup expectations after reaching consecutive Finals. Instead, the team finished 41-30-11, placed second in the Pacific Division, and suffered a first-round exit against the Anaheim Ducks.
The biggest issue was not scoring. Edmonton remained one of the NHL’s most productive offensive teams, ranking sixth in goals scored. The problem was on the other side of the puck.
The Oilers slipped to 25th in goals against, exposing defensive weaknesses that repeatedly undermined their elite forward group. Despite having Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl in their prime years, Edmonton often looked disorganized defensively and struggled to establish a consistent identity.
MORE: After winning Ted Lindsay award, Connor McDavid earns strong Hart Trophy backing
That context helps explain why management has reportedly considered Babcock. Throughout his coaching career, Babcock built a reputation for demanding accountability, structure and defensive commitment.
So, the fit is understandable. From a public-relations and league-governance standpoint, it is far more complicated.
Investigation could reshape Edmonton Oilers’s plans
The NHLPA’s request revives concerns that led to Babcock’s resignation from Columbus in 2023 before coaching a regular-season game. Questions surrounding player privacy and workplace conduct remain central to the discussion.
For Edmonton, this creates uncertainty during an offseason that already carries enormous pressure. McDavid remains under contract through 2027-28, but the organization’s championship window is no longer viewed as unlimited.
Following the playoff loss to Anaheim, both McDavid and Draisaitl expressed concern about the team’s regression. The Oilers cannot afford another season where defensive issues erase their offensive advantages.
MORE: Gary Bettman, Bill Daly break silence on Bruce Cassidy-Oilers saga
Edmonton’s need for a stronger structure is real. However, any potential Babcock hiring now appears secondary to the league’s review process. Until the investigation is completed, the Oilers may be forced to wait, reconsider alternatives, or risk further scrutiny.
For a franchise trying to maximize its title chances, the coaching search has suddenly become far more complicated than simply finding the next bench boss.
Update: Per Dreger, there is no fixed date for when this investigation will be completed. He wrote, “There’s no timeline on how quickly this can be carried out. The Oilers are aware of this. Players involved, etc in 2023 will have to be interviewed. If Babcock were to back out at this stage, a league source says there would be no reason to investigate.”
Update: Per Seravalli, “If #Oilers elect to continue down the path with Mike Babcock, sources say the #NHLPA is in receipt of “significant” additional claims from their own investigation with players that were not publicly reported in 2023. Those claims were presented to #NHL prior to his resignation.”
