The Edmonton Oilers‘ search for a new head coach has entered a complicated phase as the NHL officially begins its investigation into Mike Babcock’s 2023 resignation from the Columbus Blue Jackets.
According to Sportsnet insider Elliotte Friedman, the league will interview multiple parties as it examines whether any further action is required before Babcock can return behind an NHL bench. The investigation comes as Edmonton continues to consider the veteran coach as a candidate following the dismissal of Kris Knoblauch.
MORE: Oilers Rumors: Edmonton faces growing pressure to re-sign D-man Connor Murphy
Friedman reported that Babcock met with Oilers ownership, management and a small group of players during the hiring process. Edmonton’s leadership reportedly sought feedback from around the league and was prepared to move forward with a hire if the league cleared the path.
However, the situation has become increasingly controversial.
NHL podcaster Karman Gill reacted strongly after Friedman’s latest report.
“The Oilers would be beyond stupid to hire Mike Babcock after what Friedman has reported today,” Gill said. “You are desperate to make your team better and to win. Why would you bring in a coach who makes your location even less desirable?”
Oilers’ concerns extend beyond the investigation
The biggest development may not be the investigation itself but the reaction around the league.
Friedman reported that several agents representing Edmonton players voiced concerns about the possibility of Babcock joining the organization. Some agents reportedly expressed discomfort with the idea of clients being traded to Edmonton if Babcock became head coach.
“Several agents of Edmonton players who were not involved in direct conversations with Babcock also voiced concerns, adding they didn’t like the idea of clients being traded there, either,” Friedman wrote.
That creates a potential problem for a franchise already operating in a competitive market for player acquisition. Edmonton can attract talent because of stars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, but maintaining that advantage is critical.
The NHLPA has also voiced objections during discussions surrounding a possible hiring, adding another layer of scrutiny.
MORE: NHLPA’s Marty Walsh says players aren’t driving Oilers’ Mike Babcock pursuit
Why Edmonton Oilers remains interested?
From a hockey standpoint, Edmonton’s interest is understandable.
The Oilers targeted experience, accountability, and a coach capable of challenging a veteran roster. Babcock’s resume includes a Stanley Cup championship and years of success at the NHL level.
The organization was denied permission to interview Bruce Cassidy, while Peter Laviolette ultimately joined Los Angeles. Those developments narrowed the field and increased Babcock’s relevance in the search.
MORE: Oilers await Vegas decision as Bruce Cassidy saga enters new phase with Golden Knights’ SCF loss
Still, coaching hires are about more than systems and structure. Culture, player trust and organizational reputation matter just as much.
As the NHL investigation moves forward, the Oilers face a significant decision. Even if Babcock is ultimately cleared, Edmonton must determine whether the potential benefits outweigh the growing concerns surrounding his candidacy.
