The Edmonton Oilers’ decision to fire head coach Kris Knoblauch has quickly turned into one of the NHL offseason’s biggest talking points, with Toronto Sun columnist Steve Simmons sharply criticizing general manager Stan Bowman for the move.
Knoblauch and assistant coach Mark Stuart were dismissed on May 14 after Edmonton’s disappointing first-round playoff exit against the Anaheim Ducks. The Oilers finished the regular season with a 41-30-11 record and struggled to build consistency despite having Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl leading the roster.
Still, Simmons argued the blame falls far more on management than coaching.
“Kris Knoblauch was hired to coach the Oilers after they had bottomed out mid-season three years ago,” Simmons wrote. “He took them, in his first season, to within a goal of the Stanley Cup. In his second year, they went back to the Stanley Cup final. You can’t do much better than that.”
MORE: ‘Ugly’: Ryan Whitney rips Edmonton Oilers after Kris Knoblauch firing
Questions surrounding Oilers’ GM Stan Bowman’s roster decisions
Simmons pointed directly at Bowman’s roster management during the past two seasons. He criticized the Oilers for missing out on key free-agent targets, failing to stabilize the goaltending situation, and handing out poor contracts that weakened roster depth.
“Over the past two years, general manager Stan Bowman got snookered on a free-agency signing deal by the St. Louis Blues, failed to pick up a goaltender of consequence, signed some bad contracts, and lessened his roster exponentially,” Simmons added.
MORE: ‘He was so upset’: Edmonton Oilers owner Daryl Katz reportedly pushed for Kris Knoblauch firing
The Oilers’ defensive structure regressed badly this season. Edmonton allowed 269 goals, ranking among the league’s weakest defensive teams. A midseason gamble on Tristan Jarry failed to solve the club’s ongoing crease problems, while the blue line struggled to protect leads consistently.
McDavid’s blunt assessment after the playoff loss added to the pressure surrounding the organization. The captain described Edmonton as “an average team with high expectations,” a comment that reflected growing frustration inside the locker room.
MORE: ‘Not getting paid $10M’: NHL analyst says Oilers fans are blaming the wrong problem
Simmons blamed Bowman’s decisions, saying, “So, the coach who took them from nowhere to somewhere got shown the door, and the GM who took them from somewhere to nowhere remains in charge.”
Oilers’ coaching change may not solve deeper issues
The firing feels more like a pressure response than a structural solution. Knoblauch guided Edmonton to consecutive Stanley Cup Final appearances and recently signed a three-year extension in October 2025. Coaches with that level of postseason success rarely become available this quickly.
Bowman defended the move by saying the team needed “a different voice” and more accountability. However, Edmonton now searches for its 10th head coach in 15 years, continuing a cycle that has produced instability behind the bench.
MORE: ‘He has made mistakes’: NHL analyst calls out Oilers GM Stan Bowman after disappointing season
Reports linking former Vegas Golden Knights coach Bruce Cassidy to the vacancy suggest the Oilers want a stronger defensive identity moving forward. Still, the next coach will face the same roster flaws unless management improves the goaltending, defensive depth, and bottom-six consistency.
So, Simmons’ criticism reflects a larger concern. Edmonton changed the coach, but the bigger questions still surround the roster construction itself.
